book_wench (book_wench) wrote,

The Dresden Files

Many years ago, I came across a series that had, at the time, maybe four books in it. Since I like both fantasy and mysteries (though the traditional hard-boiled genre is not my favorite), I gave it a try. I really liked the first book. I didn't care as much for the 2nd for some reason (I have since speculated that it was my mood at the time), so I didn't go on to the third immediately. But eventually I did, and I liked it enough that I went on to the fourth, and I liked that even better.

After that, of course, I had to wait for Jim Butcher to write more, and I got my Dresden fix every year or so. My personal favorite remains Dead Beat (at least so far), but I didn't read the penultimate book, Changes, because what I heard about the ending led me to speculate that it might be the last of the series. So I was saving it for a special occasion. Then Ghost Story came out and it turned out I needn't have worried. 

Then the other day, a copy of the audiobook of Dead Beat came into the store. Like I said, it was always one of my favorites, and since I recently acquired a 40-minute commute to work, I thought I might as well give it a try. I fell in love with James Marsters' reading of the text, and in love with the book all over again. So I embarked on listening to *all* the audiobooks, in order, and also to reading them over again. I have to say, it's given me a very different appreciation of the series. The arc of the overall story comes out much more strongly if you read them all back to back, and I find it really adds something when you don't have to search your memory for references because they're all still fresh in your mind.

It was from here that I finally approached Changes and now Ghost Story. I've only just started Ghost Story, so I won't comment on it, but I had a few thought on Changes, and on Turn Coat, the preceding book. 


In both books I wasn't too fond of the earlier parts. In Turn Coat, this had largely to do with the "the-butler-did-it" motif introduced early on. I kept hoping that it would turn out to be a blind, that it was a clever misdirection on Butcher's part. But, no, as it turned out, it really was the old cliche. I really honestly felt that a plot element that had run for several books deserved to have a better conclusion, and the answer should not have been a character that we had never met before. Additionally, there were plot holes you could drive a Mac truck through. But the second half was so spot-on emotionally that I didn't care a whit about any of the rest by the time I got there. Butcher even made up for Peabody with the introduction of Cristos. I have rarely encountered a scene as emotionally satisfying as the one with Morgan at the end. And, to a lesser extent, the scene with Luccio.

In Changes, I mostly felt that poor Harry was getting hammered on just a little *too* much in the earlier part of the book. But again, Butcher pulled it out in the second half, and especially with the slam-bang ending. I mean, I sure didn't see that coming. Not even a little bit, and it was heart-wrenching once I got there. I was sort of dreading the end, since I'd heard what happened, but actually I really liked it. 

As an aside, I was talking to my agent about the Dresden Files the other day, and she mentioned the phrase "urban fantasy." I was a little startled. I know what urban fantasy is, of course, but I've never actually read any--as a genre it doesn't particularly appeal to me. But what I thought was funny was that I've never thought of the Dresden books as urban fantasy, even though they clearly are. Thinking it over, I decided it was probably because when I first encountered them, urban fantasy wasn't as common as it is now and might not even have been on my radar at the time.

Anyway, I've immensely enjoyed my re-reading of the series, and I've found that, taken as a whole instead of individually, they have a much more epic quality to them than I had remembered. I'm awfully sorry that I only have one book left.
Tags: harry dresden, jim butcher, the dresden files

  • Me and Unconscious Bias

    I’m not a racist and no, there isn’t a but coming. I just wasn’t brought up that way, and it would never occur to me to treat someone differently…

  • Just an Amusing Story

    It's last week, and I get a call from Crissie, who is fussed because her husbandish, Shaun, has been abruptly called away on a business trip to…

  • Update

    Last weekend marked the end of my personal NaNoWriMo--CaNoWriMo if you will. I was hoping to get to the end of the first draft in that time, but I…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.